Faith Over Comfort: Lessons from Jeremiah and Peter

Monday of the Eighteenth Week in Ordinary Time

First Reading: Jeremiah 28:1-17
Responsorial Psalm: Psalm 119:29, 43, 79, 80, 95, 102
Gospel: Matthew 14:22-36
Daily readings: https://bible.usccb.org/bible/readings/080326.cfm

Two prophets stand in the house of the LORD. Hananiah announces what everyone wants to hear: within two years, the exile ends. The yoke breaks. God will bring everyone home. He is confident. The crowd wants to believe him. He even takes the wooden yoke from Jeremiah's neck and snaps it dramatically. And Jeremiah's response is striking — he does not immediately argue. He says: amen, may it be so. I hope you are right. But here is the problem: the prophets who came before both of us foretold war, suffering, pestilence. A prophet who predicts peace is only confirmed as true when it happens. Then God speaks to Jeremiah privately: by breaking the wooden yoke, Hananiah has forged an iron one.

There is a warning in that for a Monday morning. The comfortable word is not always the true word. The voice that tells us everything will resolve quickly and painlessly, that we can avoid the difficult thing, that we do not need to sit with the hard truth — that voice can feel like consolation and still be leading us somewhere worse. The psalm asks for something more demanding: remove from me the way of falsehood. Teach me your statutes. Let my heart be perfect in your decrees, that I not be put to shame.

Then Peter does something extraordinary and something very human in the same thirty seconds. He sees Jesus walking on the water and asks to come. Jesus says one word: come. Peter gets out of the boat — which is itself remarkable — and begins to walk. And then he notices the wind. He looks away from Jesus toward the storm around him. And he sinks. Jesus catches him immediately. "O you of little faith, why did you doubt?" It is not a rebuke so much as a question worth sitting with. The wind was real. The storm was real. But so was Jesus, and Peter was walking toward him. What changed was not the storm. What changed was what Peter was looking at.


A few questions to sit with today:

1. Is there a comfortable voice in my life right now — an easy reassurance I keep choosing — that may be more like Hananiah's word than Jeremiah's? Am I willing to let the psalm's prayer be mine: remove from me the way of falsehood?

2. Peter got out of the boat. That part is easy to skip past. Is there something God has been saying "come" to me about — something that would require stepping out — that I have been staying in the boat to avoid?

3. When did I last take my eyes off Jesus and start looking at the wind instead? What was the wind — the specific anxiety, the specific distraction — and how did it feel when I shifted my gaze?

4. Jesus caught Peter immediately. Not after a speech, not after he proved himself — immediately. Do I believe he will catch me that fast when I am sinking?


One small thing for tomorrow:

When you feel the wind pick up tomorrow — the anxiety, the discouraging news, the voice that says it is not going to work — try looking back at Jesus before you respond. Not away from the storm, but toward him while the storm is still there. One redirect. See what happens.


Lord Jesus, you said come and Peter came — and when he sank you caught him before he went under. I want to get out of the boat more often. I want to notice when I am choosing the comfortable word over the true one, and when I am looking at the wind instead of you. Help me to want what the psalm asks for: not the easy path, but the true one. Remove from me the way of falsehood. Teach me your statutes. And when I start to sink — which I will — stretch out your hand immediately the way you did for Peter. I trust that you will. May Mary, who stepped out of every comfortable ordinary expectation to say yes to you, pray for me when the wind is loud. Amen.


If you'd like to share: what is the wind in your life right now that keeps pulling your eyes away from Jesus — and what would it take to look back toward him?

Leave a comment