Understanding Nathanael: From Skepticism to Faith

Feast of Saint Bartholomew, Apostle

First Reading: Revelation 21:9b-14

Responsorial Psalm: Psalm 145:10-11, 12-13, 17-18

Gospel: John 1:45-51

Daily readings: https://bible.usccb.org/bible/readings/082426.cfm

Philip finds his friend Nathanael — the man we celebrate today as Saint Bartholomew — and tells him they have found the one Moses and the prophets wrote about. Jesus of Nazareth. And Nathanael, being an honest man, says what he thinks: Can anything good come from Nazareth? It is not a hostile question. It is a real one. He is not pretending. Philip does not argue with him. He just says: come and see. And that is enough. Nathanael comes.

Jesus sees him walking over and says something remarkable before Nathanael has said a word. Here is a true child of Israel. There is no duplicity in him. Nathanael is startled. How do you know me? And Jesus answers: before Philip called you, I saw you under the fig tree. Something in that lands. Not an explanation, not a proof — just the fact that Jesus saw him before he came, before he said a word, before he made any decision. Nathanael answers the only way he can: Rabbi, you are the Son of God; you are the King of Israel. His skepticism dissolved not by argument but by being known. Jesus tells him: you will see greater things than this.

Bartholomew went on to see them. Tradition says he carried the Gospel to India, to Armenia, through Mesopotamia and Parthia. He gave his whole life — and at the end, in Armenia, tradition says he gave his body too, martyred for the faith he received the afternoon Philip brought him to see. He had gone from Can anything good come from Nazareth to the ends of the earth, because one day Jesus saw him under a tree and called him by name. Today’s first reading gives us the vision he spent his life moving toward: the holy city Jerusalem coming down out of heaven, its foundation walls inscribed with the names of the twelve apostles of the Lamb. His name is there.

A few questions to sit with today:

1. Philip said “come and see” — no long argument, just an invitation. Is there someone in my life who might need a simple invitation from me rather than a persuasive case? What is one small “come and see” I could offer?

2. Jesus said to Nathanael: there is no duplicity in you. If Jesus said something like that about me today — naming the thing he sees as true in me — what do I think he would say? Can I sit with that without dismissing it?

3. Nathanael’s doubt was honest, not hostile. Are there honest doubts or questions I have been carrying about my faith that I have not brought to Jesus yet? What would it look like to bring them, the way Nathanael did?

4. Jesus saw Bartholomew before he arrived. Is there a place in my life right now where I feel unseen — at work, at home, in my own prayer — and need to hear that Jesus already sees me there?

One small thing for tomorrow:

Think of one person in your life who might be on the outside of faith — skeptical, indifferent, or just distant. Tomorrow, say one word of gentle invitation to them. Not a sermon. Just a “come and see.”

Lord Jesus, you saw Bartholomew under the fig tree before he even knew your name. You see me now, in whatever ordinary place I am sitting, with whatever doubts or questions I am carrying. Thank you for not waiting until I have it all figured out before you call me by name. Make me more like Bartholomew — honest enough to ask real questions, and open enough to come when someone says come and see. May his example give me courage to carry your name into places that seem unlikely, without knowing where the road leads, trusting that you already see me there. Amen.

If you would like to share: is there a doubt or question about faith you once had that Jesus met in an unexpected way?

Leave a comment